Skip to main content
  •  Book a Tour
  •  Calendar
  •  (65) 64633201
  • Quick Links

Apply Now

HOME
  • About
    • Head Welcome
    • Mission, Vision and Values
    • Our Story
    • Leadership and Governance
    • Accreditation and Awards
    • Academic Results
    • School Campus
  • Admissions
    • Overview
    • Campus Tour
    • Application Process
    • Tuition and Fees
    • Open House
    • Scholarships
    • School Bus
    • School Uniforms
  • Academics
    • Kindergarten
    • IB Primary Years Programme
    • IB Middle Years Programme
    • IB Diploma Programme
    • Languages
    • English as an Additional Language
    • Service Learning
    • Education Technology
  • Chatsworth Life
    • Athletics and Sports
    • The Arts
    • CCAs and ECAs
    • Beyond the Classroom
    • House System and Student Leadership
    • Student Services
    • Food and Nutrition
    • School Health
  • Community
    • Chatsworth In The Community
    • Chatsworth Blog
    • Phoenix Times Newsletter
    • Community Voices
    • Chatsworth Parent Group
  • Contact
    • Staff Directory
    • Careers
    • Location Map
  • School Matters

    Observational Drawing - teaching students how to see like an artist

    Breadcrumb

    1. Home
    2. Chatsworth Blog
    3. Teachers as Vehicles for Resilience
    Back To Blog Listing
    Previous ArticleNext Article
    Open House April 2023

    Observational Drawing - teaching students how to see like an artist

    Draw what you see, not what you know
    Cory Desmond, Art & Design Teacher
    24th Jun 2022
    clipholder

    Over the course of my career teaching the visual arts I have come to be more judicious about telling students to “draw with your eyes, not with your hand”. One must be mindful of direct translation, especially in a non-native English speaking environment.  What I am trying to convey to students is to draw what they see, not what they think they see. In other words, to ‘draw’ with their eyes, not with their minds.

    It’s very easy to draw what our intellect tells us something looks like, as opposed to what our eyes are actually seeing. The majority of students subconsciously draw what they know, not what they see. This is most obvious when working with young children.

    It did not matter if it was a classroom in the United States, Vietnam, Argentina, or one of the world’s most vertical cities (Hong Kong), when I asked children to draw their house they all presented almost identical structures. You know the house already. You can envision it, because you are drawing from your mind, like they did - a triangle atop a square, with a door, a few windows, and usually a chimney. Either many of these works depicted a house in a cold climate, or I have had a fair share of child arsonists, because nearly all of the aforementioned chimneys emanated smoke. I never spotted a chimney in Vietnam, Hong Kong, etc., or so many identical houses with the omnipresent vertical and horizontal support structures in each window. Nonetheless, what students presented was their house.

    children-in-yard

    (Example of a child’s house drawing, Free Stock Photo - Public Domain Pictures)

    You might think this would differ if the students draw directly from observation, but it does not, because they still draw what they know instead of what they see. They have not yet developed the skill of acute visual analysis. Give a 4-year-old a mirror and set them up to draw a self-portrait.  Before you finish passing out materials, others will have finished. What will this masterpiece be? Two dots for eyes, a curved line for a mouth, and four appendages (limbs) radiating from a circle that serves as, both, the head and entire torso. Most will have hair, some will have noses, few will have ears. This is when I begin probing for more careful visual analysis. After we address the missing neck and so on, to elicit a reaction and more keen anatomisation, I tell the children that they all have hair on their face! After some objections, and student-made comments about my own facial hair, they agree with the more discerning analysis of their face, and all add eyebrows to their portraits.

    child's self portrait

    (Example of a child's self-portrait, Free Stock Photo - Public Domain Pictures)

    At the secondary level, this propensity to draw from the mind is also assessed formatively by watching students' eyes predominantly affix on their drawing surfaces instead of the subject matter they are illustrating. I interrupt and encourage students to critically analyse the subject so as to circumvent their eyes from being deceived by their perception and acumen. As said by Andy Warhol, "Perception precedes reality".  When using critical observation, students' eyes share time looking at the subject matter and their drawing surface. Their eyes dash back and forth, guiding their hand.

    Interested in this phenomenon and eager to show students the results of this practice, I conducted a ‘study’ where students were first simply asked to draw a binder clip from observation. Their approach and methodology was completely unguided and independent. Some students decided to suggest areas of light and dark (value) in their work, while others ended with contour line drawings.

    clip1_withoutinstructionclip2_withoutinstruction
    clip3_withoutinstructionclip4_withoutinstruction

    (Student work - Alex, Braylon, Lincoln, Tate, unguided binder clip drawings, Year 7)


    The following lesson students were led by teacher instruction, much of which consistently emphasised the importance of visual analysis while remaining cognisant of our deceptive minds.  A binder clip was placed directly in front of each student and not allowed to be moved. This helps to eliminate the distance the eye has to travel between the drawing surface and the subject matter. It also provides a consistent viewing angle. Drawing subject matter that moves is exponentially more difficult than their inanimate counterparts, however, many students cause their object to shift by constantly observing from slightly different angles (i.e. moving themselves).  Sometimes students sit upright, while other times they crouch over. This inconsistency invites adversity. It changes perspective, proportion, light, and much more.

    Students' mark-making was constantly challenged and questioned in order to continuously evaluate if marks made were based on what they see, or assume. At times, areas of the binder clip were not visible to the student, but evident in their drawing. This obviously causes the work to look inaccurate. When drawing from observation, if you cannot see it, do not draw it. It sounds obvious, but the mind can be deceitful when it comes to perception.

    Values were broken down into three: light, mid, and dark. To simplify and reduce the visual information present, the classroom lights were turned off so that the window served as the single source of light. The analysis of value progressed from identifying highlights to ultimately looking at a variety of shadows and reflected light. Observing these minute details and ‘seeing like an artist’ is what allows one to achieve accuracy and likeness in their work. When it comes to portraits, this is the difference between recognising and capturing the different shape, size, and proportion of one person's eye versus others.
     

    clip1_withinstructionclip2_withinstruction
    clip3_withinstructionclip4_withinstruction

    (Student work - Alex, Braylon, Lincoln, Tate,, guided drawing of a binder clip, Year 7)


    In the end there is not a consensus in the art community surrounding the idea of simply drawing what you see. Many are quick to acknowledge the importance of basing what you see on the knowledge of what you know, within the structure of your subject matter. For example, having knowledge and understanding of human anatomy facilitates more accurate figure drawings, and should not be ignored.

    Ultimately, ‘seeing’ and ‘knowing’ work in conjunction, hence the importance of the transfer of learning. In any case, the next time you have an opportunity, try to analyse your field of vision with greater critical analysis. Observe, and experience the world like an artist.

    Find out more about the arts at Chatsworth and how we inspire, educate, and enlighten our students, or book a tour of our campus today.

    __________________________________

    Sources cited

    Ltd, B. (n.d.). Children’s Person Drawing Free Stock Photo - Public Domain Pictures. Copyright (c) 2007 - 2022 by Bobek Ltd. Retrieved June 15, 2022, from https://www.publicdomainpictures.net/en/view-image.php?image=37873&picture=childrens-person-drawing

    Ltd, B. (n.d.-a). Children In Yard Free Stock Photo - Public Domain Pictures. Copyright (c) 2007 - 2022 by Bobek Ltd. Retrieved June 14, 2022, from https://www.publicdomainpictures.net/en/view-image.php?image=56144&picture=children-in-yard

    Nicolaïdes Kimon. (2021). The Natural Way to Draw: A Working Plan for Art Study. Souvenir Press.

    Edwards, Betty. (2016). Drawing on the right side of The brain: The definitive, 4th edition. Souvenir Press Ltd.

    Andy Warhol quote. (n.d.). QuoteNova.Net; www.quotenova.net. Retrieved June 15, 2022, from https://www.quotenova.net/authors/andy-warhol/q6k3ag

    Share this article:

    Search form

    Categories

    • Primary School
    • Secondary School
    • Holistic Education
    • School Community
    • Early Childhood

    Recent Posts

    Chatsworth International School provides numerous opportunities for students throughout our year groups to interact and work collaboratively
    13th Mar 2023

    Preparing Your Child for Move to Secondary school: Tips from Chatsworth International School

    Secondary students at Chatsworth International School are taken outside the classroom to gain different learning experienes
    28th Feb 2023

    From Classroom to Community_ How It Can Help International Students Learn Effectively

    Year 6 students presented their futuristic cityscapes as part of their unit of inquiry
    13th Feb 2023

    Communities of Learning at an IB School

    Chatsworth offers the the Primary Years Programme, Middle Years Programme and Diploma Programme of the International Baccalaureate (IB) curriculum
    17th Jan 2023

    Choosing the Right Curriculum: A Guide to the IBDP and A Levels

     
    Book a Tour
     
    Enquire Now
     
    Apply Now

    1

    •  72 Bukit Tinggi Road, Singapore 289760
    •  (65) 6463 3201
    •  information.bt@chatsworth.com.sg
    • logo1

    • IB logo
    • Edutrust logo

    • Earcos logo
    • logo5
    • child safe guarding logo

    All rights reserved © Chatsworth International School 2023

    • Personal Data Protection Policy
    • Safeguarding Policy
    • Haze Policy
    • Website Privacy Policy
    • Sitemap

    Connect with us

    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  

    CPE registration number: 199405288W

    Registration period: 30 June 2019 – 29 June 2023